Repository navigation
Can we deprecate LINKABLE and RELOCATABLE settings #25262
Description
These settings I believe were created as part of enabled dynamic linking, but its not clear that they are useful on their own.
Being able to remove these settings or at least make them internal would allow for bunch of simplification. Especially since we are trying to move towards a MAIN_MODULE that is not RELOCATABLE, keeping the public RELOCATABLE setting around would really complicate things in that world.
See #12682
Reacted by Alon Zakai
Activity
Deprecate RELOCATABLE and LINKABLE settings.
Deprecate RELOCATABLE and LINKABLE settings.
Deprecate RELOCATABLE and LINKABLE settings.
Deprecate RELOCATABLE and LINKABLE settings.
Deprecate RELOCATABLE and LINKABLE settings. (#25265)
Remove references to `RELOCATABLE`/`LINKABLE` from test code. NFC
Remove references to `RELOCATABLE`/`LINKABLE` from test code. NFC
Remove references to `RELOCATABLE`/`LINKABLE` from test code. NFC
Remove references to `RELOCATABLE`/`LINKABLE` from test code. NFC
kripken commentedon Oct 21, 2025
sgtm (why am I assigned?)
sbc100 commentedon Oct 21, 2025
Sorry , my mistake.
Remove references to `RELOCATABLE`/`LINKABLE` from test code. NFC
Remove references to `RELOCATABLE`/`LINKABLE` from test code. NFC
Remove references to `RELOCATABLE`/`LINKABLE` from test code. NFC (#2…
makslevental commentedon Dec 8, 2025
I dunno if it's too late to reconsider but I would humbly request you do not kill
LINKABLE. See #25911.sbc100 commentedon Dec 8, 2025
No, not too late.
Deprecate RELOCATABLE and LINKABLE settings. (emscripten-core#25265)
Remove references to `RELOCATABLE`/`LINKABLE` from test code. NFC (em…